Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

‘We are confused; Justice System in disarray’ – Residents

November 4th, 2014 | Tags:
Magistrates (l-r) Ayana Baptiste-DaBreo, Tamia Richards (Snr Mag.) and Dr. Velon L. John. Photo: Internet sources
They then compared to the case of Edmond Colaire 33 years old who was sentenced to 15 months behind bars when he appeared before Magistrate Ayana Baptise-DaBreo at the Magistrate's Court on October 29, 2014 despite his begging for mercy. Photo: VINO
They then compared to the case of Edmond Colaire 33 years old who was sentenced to 15 months behind bars when he appeared before Magistrate Ayana Baptise-DaBreo at the Magistrate's Court on October 29, 2014 despite his begging for mercy. Photo: VINO
Kai de Castro (left), 26, of Sea Cows Bay and Keon Leonard, 24, of Botanic Station, a high school teacher and a graphic artist, were charged with possession of an illegal weapon and explosives (ammunition). Photo: VINO/File
Kai de Castro (left), 26, of Sea Cows Bay and Keon Leonard, 24, of Botanic Station, a high school teacher and a graphic artist, were charged with possession of an illegal weapon and explosives (ammunition). Photo: VINO/File
The two interdicted police officers Wendell Anthony and Marvin Robinson who were found guilty on October 8, 2014 by Magistrate Dr. Velon L. John for beating 18 year old Brandon George back in 2012 were today October 30, 2014 each fined $2k at the Prospect Reef Magistrate's Court. Photo: VINO/File
The two interdicted police officers Wendell Anthony and Marvin Robinson who were found guilty on October 8, 2014 by Magistrate Dr. Velon L. John for beating 18 year old Brandon George back in 2012 were today October 30, 2014 each fined $2k at the Prospect Reef Magistrate's Court. Photo: VINO/File
Shawn Williams was fined $2K for the firearm charge for which he was found guilty. Photo: VINO/File
Shawn Williams was fined $2K for the firearm charge for which he was found guilty. Photo: VINO/File
ROAD TOWN, Tortola, VI – Yesterday afternoon November 3, 2014 this news site was called to a street corner meeting of a group of concerned residents who are calling for a public forum to have issues about the justice system explained in ‘laymans terms’ to them.

The group included to a greater extent senior students of the Elmore Stoutt High School (ESHS), some H. Lavity Stoutt Community College (HLSCC) first year students and others from various sectors of society. The group said that they usually meet informally as friends and discuss things that are positive and negatively affecting their lives.

“We never really thought about going to the news people with these things but we saw you passing (VINO reporter) and immediately we thought that we could share our concerns with you because we think VINO have the guts to be candid and everybody reads VINO if they like y’all or not they read VINO,” one person from the group declared.

They pleaded not to be named as most of them said that some of the situations they are referring to involved even some of their family members. “We love our people, right is right and wrong is wrong but we feel that we need to understand why and how certain things happen,” one said.

According one of the youths they became very concerned recently about the way they have been observing justice being dispensed especially in the Magistrate’s Court and they called the names of Senior Magistrate Ms Tamia Richards and Magistrates Dr Velon L. John and Ayana Baptiste-DaBreo.

“To a greater extent I seem to be thinking that Magistrate Ayana is doing most things fairly but there are some questions. I don’t know what to say about Ms Richards and Dr John is a force to be reckoned with,” said one young woman.

They all had particular issues primarily with the cases of Shawn Williams who was fined $2k and a two year suspended sentence after being found guilty of firearm, Keon Leonard and Kai DeCastro who were found guilty for the offense of carrying an unlicensed firearm among other offenses and were both fined $2k each payable immediately and a suspended sentence of two years imprisonment for the firearm offense.

The other was of two interdicted police officers Wendell Anthony and Marvin Robinson who were found guilty on October 8, 2014 by Magistrate Dr. Velon L. John for beating 18 year old Brandon George back in 2012 and were each fined $2k.

They then compared to the case of Edmond Colaire 33 years old who was sentenced to 15 months behind bars when he appeared before Magistrate Ayana Baptise-DaBreo at the Magistrate's Court on October 29, 2014 despite his begging for mercy.

“The others had nothing to say before sentencing and in our judgment the other cases were much more daring and they got a chance. We are so confused and we would love to see the Minister for Education and even the Premier, Hon [Julian Fraser RA], Hon [Andrew A. Fahie], we want them to help us find a forum where we can get better understanding of what’s going on,” said one on behalf of the group.

“We got serious political questions for them too that’s not related to court. Something like Follow the Movement forum will work,” one said.  

30 Responses to “‘We are confused; Justice System in disarray’ – Residents”

  • all on different pages (04/11/2014, 08:42) Like (9) Dislike (3) Reply
    3 blind mice or 3 stooges????
  • vi (04/11/2014, 08:46) Like (18) Dislike (3) Reply
    It have a lot of people sharing this concern. People are confused about
    Colaire sentencing and talking about it.
  • xxxxx (04/11/2014, 08:55) Like (52) Dislike (1) Reply

    It sickens me to the core to know that a man LITERALLY BEGGED for mercy and got thrown behind bars for 15 months for an old shot gun (no ammunition) and, to the very place where it is alleged that another man resides for making an attempt on the individual’s life. If the magistrate court is sending a message, it is sending a message of dysfunction. There seems to be a power struggle in there. I wonder what the MESSAGE (to the BVI masses) will be in reference to the recent matter on guns and ammunition found in the home down west side.
  • xxxxxxxx (04/11/2014, 08:57) Like (3) Dislike (0) Reply
    well saw look trouble
  • DopeBoy (04/11/2014, 09:19) Like (28) Dislike (1) Reply
    When even the school children start noticing and cant seem to understand the situations, then you definitely know some things just aint right!
  • Blogfrog (04/11/2014, 09:25) Like (14) Dislike (0) Reply
    ONLY VINO got the balls to stand up, and ask these questions. Intervention is necessary to divert anarchy. We are seeing the smoke! Please we don't want to see the fire or lava.
  • no consistency (04/11/2014, 09:32) Like (31) Dislike (0) Reply
    It appears as though the Magistrate's Court isn't guided by any laws when sentencing. It's like a royal circus where each magistrate charge or sentence defendants based on how they feel at the moment. If they had a good night, then persons are asked to go the church, if they have problems at home you get an outrageous sentence, if things are not soo bad and they're in an in-between mood, then you get a thousand dollars bail or 2 years in prison. The hold thing sounds like they have sentences in a bag raffling and whatever comes up, then that's it. It needs to be addressed because the guys who have a joint to smoke to use on themselves have a lot more to fear than the man who have a whole military set up with ammu which can blow people to pieces. Sad to say though, like everything else, its just another 'talk' without action because that's who we are.
  • Citizen (04/11/2014, 09:37) Like (8) Dislike (1) Reply
    Imagine the youths want to speak to the politicians. I hope they answer there call
  • ccc (04/11/2014, 09:44) Like (13) Dislike (0) Reply
    Good piece vino get writing truth to power
  • miss (04/11/2014, 09:47) Like (9) Dislike (1) Reply
    if the youths noticed and speaking up about it then you must know its serious.
  • Enforcement is Key (04/11/2014, 09:48) Like (13) Dislike (8) Reply
    Baptiste is making the right enforcement decisions. It appears she is doing as BVIslanders are blogging - that is by upholding laws and sentencing correctly. It is however the other two which are throwing fines all about. Fines that are a joke of $1-2K with no incarcerations for the very serious firearm crimes. It is these crimes that the BVI are trying to eradicate. There should be no mercy for these type of crimes, which is clearly what Baptiste is providing. Let's have a concensus among our judicial system.
  • wize up (04/11/2014, 10:32) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    the citizens must stand-up; it was done back in the 60s & 70s so it is nothing new; the persons we have elected really do not look out for the well-being of citizens of these virgin islands...it is simply my opinion, crime involving a deadly weapon the fines should higher; crimes involving drugs the fines should also be higher...you will never ever stop crimes but trying to deter crime is a good factor...its refreshing to know that persons are concerned; that's great
  • ------------------- (04/11/2014, 10:46) Like (9) Dislike (0) Reply
    The legal system like the political and house of assembly are the same; a big joke and inconsistent
  • Equal Rights and Justice (04/11/2014, 10:58) Like (13) Dislike (1) Reply
    Excellent Article Vino, This cannot continue where there is no justice there is no peace. This is soooo unfair the these boys get such a slap on the risk because of who their parents are affiliated with and this poor man begged and begged for mercy for a old gun and got the time.

    Something needs to be done with regards to standing by the Laws of our Land.!!!!!!!!!!
  • Len (04/11/2014, 11:17) Like (26) Dislike (0) Reply
    I really applaud the students. I am a BV Islander and must say that from the recent decisions especially that of Edmund changed my mind negatively about the justice system. We cannot take such decisions lightly and something needs to be done....now! I'd also like to see something done with regards to the Colaire decision.

    After reading that article it almost brought tears to my eyes. This young man begged for mercy! Mercy (our justice system) said no! Yet that same justice system of ours find it so easy to pat others on the shoulder with a small fine and suspended sentence and send them on their way. I love my country and that's why I speak!

    Thanks VINO for the great work!
    • heartache (04/11/2014, 12:19) Like (33) Dislike (0) Reply
      It brought "tears" to my eyes too...meaning: I felt the pain. It hit me hard and more so when the sentence handed out on the other 2 the following day for a loaded semi-automatic that was thrown out of a car during a POLICE CHASE!
  • Ok Then! (04/11/2014, 11:39) Like (11) Dislike (1) Reply
    I hope there will be a follow up story to this soon; very interesting.
  • weed (04/11/2014, 12:59) Like (4) Dislike (7) Reply
    this is the BVI the NDP has started the disrespect for law and order and remeber the white house anything goes
  • Ruff dogg (04/11/2014, 13:02) Like (9) Dislike (0) Reply
    It's all about who they don't like.
  • Positive Vibes (04/11/2014, 15:42) Like (3) Dislike (15) Reply
    I think some people are not reading and understanding the sentences on these various cases. The guy that was sentenced to 15 months was sentenced by a different magistrate. She clearly stated she could have given the guy a fine but choose not to. These magistrates have the most DISCRETION in the WORLD and CAN CHANGE OR RUIN someone’s LIFE. Hate it of LOVE it Mr. John uses his Discretion. Why pack these guys in prison where there aren’t any proper REHABILITION. Think about it. Stop Knocking down the youths and encourage them to do better given that they got a Second Chance to correct their wrongs. We continuously fight against one another and wish bad for our fellow brothers and sisters. Instead of always being negative, breed positivity and our little island will be a much better place.
    • Point ? (04/11/2014, 16:26) Like (8) Dislike (0) Reply
      That's not the point of this article...
    • ehem (04/11/2014, 18:40) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
      Mr. John fair? Hah! Wow! Far it goes it seems like they both was found guilty for the offence of possession of firearm. If that is true they were then also found guilty for the traffic offences. Now how can that be possible. If a driver refuse to stop can I be garaged for driving offences when clearly I was not driving? Seeking clarity on this one. so am to pay $$$$$ for a firearm and receive suspended sentences for traffic offences I have not committed? Oh well it's just a record. All these offences committed and $2,000 is all you pay. This is the dilemma these kids are battling with, it's a most baddling one to figure out. There is a need for a forum where lawyers, layman, magistrates can have these questions answered.
  • ehem (04/11/2014, 18:28) Like (4) Dislike (0) Reply
    The sentence for cola ire was a strange one for me. He pled guilty from the get go. Usually there is some reward for this as the court recognize he has come clean. Usually those who comes to the court playing games are made to feel the full weight so to speak of the court by harsher sentences. So that is my ilk with the whole thing. One man man-up and get kicked in his teeth while the other lied, cast blame, defer responsibility and they are rewarded with a dabs/high five so to speak. This man plead for mercy was met with a Tyson overhand right. SMH as this one. What is up with _elon and Ms. Richards that they seem to be in tow in their sentencing and apparently incorrectly so.
  • Real (04/11/2014, 20:11) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    I am glad that this issue is raised because I for one know that these guys are getting away too easy on these gun charges.For a moment I was wondering when did we stop fighting crime? and when was it ok to get caught with a loaded gun and get away?
  • police (04/11/2014, 20:21) Like (2) Dislike (10) Reply
    It is a fact that the court must send a message when it comes to gun crimes, magistrate Dabreo did her job, is the Dr who ever he be, that is not doing his job, he just convicted to hard working police officers based on his personal feeling, this is madness, the evidence was weak and crazy and he still found these officer guilty, and many other decisions he made, this is the worst we have seen on the bench, this Dr needs to go back to politics, this is an assault on our judicial system, I have no respect for this Dr, I refuse to salute this man. waste of time and money.
  • setup (06/11/2014, 10:02) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    This is one big setup so that the oneals can get a fine also
  • rastaman (06/11/2014, 16:23) Like (2) Dislike (1) Reply
    the leaders of this country going turn this place to the wild wild west


Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.

Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.