Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

Public Service reduced from 4495 in 2010 to 'efficient' 2895 to date- David D. Archer Jr

Deputy Governor David D. Archer Jr has announced that as part of finding the right size for the local public service, there has been a steady decrease in the number of Public Officers throughout the last decade from 4495 public officers employed in 2010 to approximately 2895 employed to date. Photo: VINO/File
The Deputy Governor Mr David D. Archer JR added that compensation philosophy is a proposed new way for the Public Service to organise job positions where PwC suggests adopting the Industrial Classification of All Economic Activities (ISIC) system for the assigning of job families, subfamilies, streams, stages, and levels. Photo: GIS/Facebook
The Deputy Governor Mr David D. Archer JR added that compensation philosophy is a proposed new way for the Public Service to organise job positions where PwC suggests adopting the Industrial Classification of All Economic Activities (ISIC) system for the assigning of job families, subfamilies, streams, stages, and levels. Photo: GIS/Facebook
ROAD TOWN, Tortola, VI– Deputy Governor Mr David D. Archer Jr has announced that as part of finding the right size for the local public service, there has been a steady decrease in the number of Public Officers throughout the last decade, from 4495 public officers employed in 2010 to approximately 2895 employed to date.

“Since the world economic crisis, we have been aggressively trying to get the right size of the Public Service, and you will see significant declines,” Mr Archer Jr said.

The results come as part of the third phase of the Public Service Compensation Review, which culminated in the submission of “a compensation philosophy” from consultancy firm Pricewaterhouse Coopers (PwC), he said in a statement released on July 10, 2023.

Archer Jr added that compensation philosophy is a proposed new way for the Public Service to organise job positions where PwC suggests adopting the Industrial Classification of All Economic Activities (ISIC) system for the assigning of job families, subfamilies, streams, stages, and levels.

“You will see where decisions were made in terms of not rehiring certain positions and just trying to get the right balance with transformation, digital transformation and technology. It allows us to look at a leaner, more efficient public service.”

Review based on models in several countries 

The Deputy Governor shared that PwC has created the compensation philosophy in line with the Virgin Islands National Sustainable Development Plan and Public Service Transformation Framework, and has based their proposal on models from several different countries including the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, Jamaica, Barbados, the Cayman Islands and Mauritius. 

The Deputy Governor shared that the review has now moved into the fourth phase where both a draft and final Compensation Review Report will be created in three remaining steps.

The steps will include developing a compensation strategy, designing a compensation plan and package and adjusting the salary administration system to facilitate achieving strategic objectives.

18 Responses to “Public Service reduced from 4495 in 2010 to 'efficient' 2895 to date- David D. Archer Jr”

  • Public Service (11/07/2023, 14:53) Like (4) Dislike (1) Reply
    is a vague term. Please list the names all the BVI government ministries, offices, boards, etc. and their number of public service officers that are paid full or part time employees. 2895 seems too low. Thank you!
  • about time (11/07/2023, 15:03) Like (16) Dislike (3) Reply
    Thanks Deputy Governor. Some were just receiving salaries without any productivity. Also, you need to look into who have reached retitement age and send them home. Some have receiceved gratuity and pension after retiring, but yet want to be re employed on a contractural basis. It is not fair!
    • @ about time (12/07/2023, 07:24) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
      Indeed, life is not fair. Try living here as an expat.
      • time will tell (12/07/2023, 08:50) Like (7) Dislike (2) Reply
        While most may not like to hear it, the simple fact ot the matter is that no one has to suffer or endure unfairness in the BVI. Unlike locals who also suffer, you have a country to return to if it does not work for you in the BVI. We have no option but learn all the streets in the hell we call home!!
  • Really (11/07/2023, 15:12) Like (17) Dislike (1) Reply
    And still people cant get them increments yet?
  • Socrates (11/07/2023, 15:42) Like (7) Dislike (3) Reply
    There is no quantitative ideal number of residents per civil servant; it is situational. The drop from 4495 to 2895, 1600, was an approximate 35% drop, a significant drop. At 4495 and with a population of approximately 34,000, each civil servant service approx 7 residents; at 2895, 1 civil servant service approx 11 residents. Did the level and quality of service diminish or increase with the decrease in number of civil servants, ie, customer- oriented, responsive, and dedicated? What was the total compensation reduction? Which departments had increase in workers and which had reductions? Does the numbers include statutory bodies? What drove the number to 4495 and what is driving down the number? Is technology a factor? What is the current level of productivity and did it go up or down with the variation in numbers? If the level of productivity is low, what is the financial cost to bring it up to at least the norm? Is low productivity a drag on the civil service reputation? What grade did Price Water House give the civil service or that was part of the tasking? What are customers level of satisfaction with the civil service? Are increments other than cost of living allowances based on merit or everyone gets it? Is the civil being funded by the local taxpayers/local government and managed by the Governor’s office ideal in helping the territory move towards a full measure of self/government? Is this paternalistic behavior by the Governor helpful in the march towards towards more self-determination effort? Is the control of the civil service, police, internal security, judiciary, jail, etc a control mechanism consistent with the fear associated with colonialism dating back to slavery? Is it a matter of distrust in the leadership and management capabilities of local leaders who are primarily of African descent? Do the same controls apply to crown dependencies, ie, Isle of Man, Jersey, and Guernsey and if no, why not? Do Falkland Islands and Gibraltar fall under the same agency and if under different agencies why?
    • @ socrates (12/07/2023, 07:23) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
      Many good comments….some answers. Couple of further thoughts. Govt employees would be Belongers. There are probably about 8,000 of workig age in the Territory, so at present, more than 1/3 adult are in govt. employ. Would have been more than 50% when there were about 4,500. Figure, a median salary of $ 25k, plus $ 5 K in benefist (I’m sure it’s more), and govt payroll runs around $ 85 million a year, or about 20% of the budget. The reduction from 4,495 to 2,895 represents a cost savings of about $ 48 million (10% of the budget). It’ll be more when increments are handed out. You may recall that the some years back the govt commissioned an efficiency study. The report, like many other tax payer funded studies, was never released, although the BVI Beacon reported on the executive summary which indicated the govt had an excess 33% staff to conduct it’s stated functions. So, indeed an appearance of paternalism on the part of BVI elected governments.

      As to levels of customer satisfaction with govt. services, it’s easy to discern that scores are not great. The govt. has spent a lot of money to sent customs and immigration to several rounds of customer service training. Many employers can tell you about how work permit applications drag on. Many residents can tell you about the woes of dealing with BVI Electricity. Many residents rightfully complain about the state of the roads, schools that still fixing, Pockwood Pond, etc.

      And, regarding controls, cost control/management is an essential part of running any business, including govt. anywhere. Got nothing to do with past colonialism and everything to do with making wise use of whatever resources are at hand. Only some oil producing countries in the middle east have an unlimited supply of money, and even that will run out.
    • Aristotle (12/07/2023, 07:26) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
      Socrates, you are still a valuable annoyance like the good ole days in Ancient Athens. However, I’m anxiously waiting on the honest answer on the following question: “ Did the level and quality of service diminish or increase with the decrease in number of civil servants, ie, customer- oriented, responsive, and dedicated? waiting, waiting, waiting….. Well, if the civil service get 1) customer-oriented, 2) responsive and 3) dedicated, that will be a surprising monumental achievement and worthy of a celebration and a feather in the cap of the token Deputy Governor. Why can the Deputy Governor act for a few days sporadically but cannot be appointed Governor? Is it because he does the look to represent the crown? What look? The uncomfortable feeling people get with bringing people with a high percentage of melanin in the fold.
  • Smoke & mirrors (11/07/2023, 15:43) Like (8) Dislike (0) Reply
    ... is all an illusion. What has been done to proactively make the public service more efficient?? Tell us that. This is just another report by some other firm that cost the tax payers $$$$. I am sure this report could be put together by someone who is already being paid a salary from the government. Just give them the data. Those numbers reflect people who have retired, unfortunately passed away or people who have just decided to leave. WHEEL... and come again
  • hmm (11/07/2023, 18:27) Like (7) Dislike (0) Reply
    How many bloated politically manipulated boards created in that time?
  • island man (11/07/2023, 19:28) Like (9) Dislike (0) Reply
    Meanwhile, Departments like Water & Sewerage struggle, and current employees take up the slack by working overtime without pay.
  • my2cents (11/07/2023, 19:41) Like (5) Dislike (0) Reply
    He doesn't seem to fight for locals yet gets a serious pass on all issues.
  • drop (11/07/2023, 23:00) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    To say the number drop without saying why, leads to arriving at false and baseless conclusions such as, efficiency was improved as a result. Logical explanations for the drop may include:
    - death
    - retirement
    - transfer from the public to the private sector (mostly the more qualified may transfer leaving behind the less qualified which can impact efficiency in a negative way)
    - relocation to other countries (again, usually the more qualified persons would have explored this route)
    - going on educational leave and never returning (better opportunities elsewhere for the more qualified)

    To suggest that there was any exercise to proactively assess skill set and to take intentional steps to reduce anything to achieve efficiency is simply misleading Would it not be better to evidence efficiency by outlining what actual training has been provided to existing staff to improve their performance/efficiency and how their performance/efficiency has actually been assessed to determine the level of improvement?

    Providing a baseless set of numbers to explain efficiency is simply unfounded, lacking any supportive evidence and misleading.

    About the explanation for the PWC report, just a set of fancy words to say someone was overpaid to review current salary scales. I agree with the person/s who say that this could have been done internally. STEP 1 - list out every single job role, description and level of pay in government. STEP 2 - minimize the number of job roles by grouping similar roles together under one name, description and level of pay. STEP 3 - assign the new roles, job description and level of pay to staff. STEP 4 - clearly explain to the staff the performance indicators that need to be achieved in order to move up to the next role (higher level of compensation). STEP 5 - facilitate progression by providing tailored training to the staff.

    Shameful.
    • @drop (12/07/2023, 08:53) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
      He said more than what is quoted, this story is taken from his interview on the Government FB page.
  • Stealth (12/07/2023, 07:42) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    A high level of employees does not produce a higher level of productivity. The principle of diminishing marginal return comes into play, ie, at optimal capacity, adding more labor results in lower output. Further, it is an open secret that by necessity government by necessity is a major employer. The civil service is bloated but it it not politically smart or good politics to initiate cutbacks/layoff; it is suicidal. Neither government nor Opposition will champion it. Any reductions will come through retirement and attritions. This whole thing is a charade, smoke and mirrors, mirage, etc. Next door, our friendly neighbor to the west has or had a similar problem. During the Cyril King Admin, additional workers were hired but once hired it was extremely difficult to trim the numbers ; it was not smart politics. During the pandemic, the USVI had to stay open, for the most part, for closing would have bring another crisis , an employment crisis generating from no tourists.
  • ??? (12/07/2023, 10:57) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    Brain drain after hurricane or didn't not return after earning degrees a
    broad due to cost of living, nepotism, etc.
  • Graduate (12/07/2023, 14:28) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    Maybe if the government posted the open positions and gave everyone a fair chance, instead of saving them up for who know who, they would have workers. #FoodforThought


Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.

Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.