Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

No need for VI’S own helicopter- J. Phil Aspinall

- advises that a small lightweight aircraft is better for VI
November 19th, 2024 | Tags: Virgin Islands VISAR Phill Aspinall search rescue
A US Coast Guard helicopter. A lightweight helicopter may be more efficient for the Virgin Islands, Mr J. Phil Aspinall has stated. Photo: nhahistoricalsociety.org
Virgin Islands Search and Rescue (VISAR) has been operating in the Virgin Islands since 1988 and now has a membership of fifty volunteers. Photo: Facebook
Virgin Islands Search and Rescue (VISAR) has been operating in the Virgin Islands since 1988 and now has a membership of fifty volunteers. Photo: Facebook
From left Talking Points co-host Damion C. Grange, co-host Violet Thomas Gaul, Phil Aspinall of the Virgin Islands Search and Rescue (VISAR), and co-host Elvin G. Grant on Talking Points on November 18, 2024. Photo: Facebook
From left Talking Points co-host Damion C. Grange, co-host Violet Thomas Gaul, Phil Aspinall of the Virgin Islands Search and Rescue (VISAR), and co-host Elvin G. Grant on Talking Points on November 18, 2024. Photo: Facebook
BAUGHERS BAY, Tortola, VI— Mr J. Phil Aspinall of the Virgin Islands Search and Rescue (VISAR) has said there is no need for a rescue helicopter in the Virgin Islands (VI).

Mr Aspinall was speaking on Talking Points on ZBVI 780 AM on Monday, November 18, 2024, when co-host Damion C. Grange asked his views on the idea of the VI acquiring a helicopter.

“The reality is in the thirty-five odd years I’ve been coordinating rescues, I’ve used a helicopter maybe three or four times,” Mr Aspinall responded and added that a helicopter is a costly machine to keep going.

Small lightweight aircraft is better

Grange followed up by asking if a helicopter used for multiple purposes to include use by the police, for search and rescue and for airlifting patients from one sister island to the next would make more sense.

The search and rescue expert replied that a small lightweight aircraft is all the VI would need. One that is well-equipped and can take a stretcher if needed but not a helicopter.

Mr Aspinall, who said he served in the military for many years, explained that helicopters are five times as expensive to run per hour and have a short range.

He said search and rescue operations using something that can be in the air for several hours is better compared to a helicopter that has to refuel after about an hour and a half.

Mr Aspinall said now that VISAR has been in operation for many years, when a request for a helicopter from the US Coast Guard is made, it is approved and on its way to assist in a timely manner.

24 Responses to “No need for VI’S own helicopter- J. Phil Aspinall ”

  • hmm (19/11/2024, 08:31) Like (13) Dislike (13) Reply
    Boss, especially from Anegada, we need an aircraft that can quickly uplift patients. St.John has a boat, but the ride from Cruz Bay to Red Hook to meet the Ambulance is much shorter: less than 15 minutes when smooth and no more than 25 minutes when rough.

    What nonsense are you talking. We had a plane and it was disbanded and the drug trafficking went crazy. Who do you all think you fooling we here are not stupid we seeing the game.
  • bvibuzz (19/11/2024, 08:32) Like (7) Dislike (23) Reply
    he full of hockey sticks he just want to maintain white rule and VISAR they oppose us having our local search and recuse
    • lodger (19/11/2024, 09:44) Like (23) Dislike (1) Reply
      VISAR IS our own search and rescue. Its locals fault if very few want to join and undergo the training required to maintain the service. Who would run “our local search and rescue?”
  • TOTALLY DISAGREE (19/11/2024, 09:03) Like (16) Dislike (6) Reply
    In immediate search and rescue operations, particularly in the challenging environment of a small island territory, helicopters provide invaluable advantages that significantly surpass those of small lightweight aircraft. Helicopters possess the unique ability to hover, allowing them to search specific areas with precision and to navigate difficult terrains and obstacles, such as dense rugged coastlines, which are often prevalent here in the VI.

    Moreover, helicopters can quickly deploy rescue personnel and equipment directly to the scene, facilitating prompt medical assistance or evacuation without the need for landing, which is crucial in time-sensitive situations. Their versatility in vertical takeoff and landing means they require less space for operations, enabling them to access remote areas that might be unreachable by other means.

    In contrast, while small lightweight aircraft may have their benefits, they are limited by their need for longer runways and are less capable of operating in adverse weather conditions or challenging landscapes. In critical situations where every second counts, the life-saving capabilities of helicopters can mean the difference between life and death. Therefore, when considering the urgency and complexities involved in search and rescue missions, the deployment of helicopters should be top priority to ensure that no life is lost unnecessarily.

    A good former teacher and principal said it’s time to change tires when he realized that it was time to retire. Let a young innovative individual take the lead in our rescue who agree that we must live up to the times with the type of natural disasters occurring in our deck of the woods if you truly feel that way.
  • HE AIN'T SERIOUS (19/11/2024, 09:03) Like (9) Dislike (5) Reply
    THE HELICOPTER ???? IS MORE VERSATILE , UNLESS ITS A SEA PLANE , A LIFE IS WORTH IT
  • Rubber Duck (19/11/2024, 09:04) Like (22) Dislike (4) Reply
    We don’t need a helicopter until we need one! Somebody who might otherwise have lived will die because we don’t have a helicopter.
  • Linda (19/11/2024, 09:16) Like (14) Dislike (0) Reply
    Whether it is a helicopter or a small aircraft, One is needed for the BVI, there is an urgent need for a dedicated medical aircraft in the BVI to provide critical emergency response for the Sister Islands.

    Given the geographical challenges and time-sensitive nature of medical emergencies, having this service in place would significantly improve access to lifesaving care and transportation for residents and visitors of the Sister Islands.
    This is something the Ministrer of Health should invest into.
  • kkk (19/11/2024, 09:22) Like (5) Dislike (7) Reply

    Dah man d**b

  • de silent one (19/11/2024, 09:32) Like (15) Dislike (1) Reply
    He talks about a light plane, but that only for where there's an airport, so what happen to the peoole on JVD, guess they have to endure that same pounding on the water to get to west end, then another half hour pounding to get to the hospital. Time they get there they half dead. Whereas a helicopter can do the entire journey in less than a half hour. He's only one person opinion
  • dont mind he (19/11/2024, 09:54) Like (7) Dislike (7) Reply
    He can't fly no helicopter....He could only fly small planes....So he wants to stay relevant
  • lodger (19/11/2024, 10:02) Like (15) Dislike (0) Reply
    Helicopter. WHO WOULD PAY FOR IT.? WHO WOULD MAN IT? WHO WOULD MAINTAIN IT? A helicopter service has been offered several times over the years, but always turned down by government. Why? VISAR is a voluntary organisation, unencumbered by government control or lack of funds. Government, and indeed private persons, have been unable to run any sort of airline service for more than a few months, and police, immigration, and customs have not had much luck with their marine services.
  • YES SIR (19/11/2024, 10:05) Like (5) Dislike (1) Reply
    I completely disagree with this reasoning. We are a tourist destination with several islands. If a medical emergency occurs on one of the outer islands, whether on land or in the water, a helicopter can respond quickly, especially in isolated places.
    Having a multi-purpose helicopter that can collaborate with law enforcement agencies such as customs, immigration, and police offers for cost savings and justifies the usage of such a vessel. Helicopters can reach remote or difficult-to-access regions faster than a boat or vehicle, and they can hover over water, making them perfect for rescuing persons stuck on boats, reefs, or small islands. Helicopters can be equipped with thermal imaging and night vision to identify people in low-visibility situations at night during a rescue, which an aircraft cannot do.
    Helicopters are critical for surveying damage following a hurricane or severe disaster, and they can also bring emergency relief to affected communities if an airport is damaged or closed. They may land on small helipads, beaches, and hard-to-reach locations. They are also essential for assessing damage following hurricanes, particularly on our outer islands. They can also rescue stranded people and provide emergency relief in afflicted areas.

    The thought process must be directed toward a holistic perspective. A helicopter fits our profile since it has several islands with no landing zones and is more flexible than an airplane.



  • VG Resident (19/11/2024, 10:11) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    PC-12 is an ideal aircr.aft Will land at all BVI airports. Flies at 300 MPH. so good to go to Miami. Large cargo door so 2 stretchers can be fitted. About $2000 per hour with annuals at about $100,000. Used all over Australia
  • Bumble Bee (19/11/2024, 10:30) Like (15) Dislike (1) Reply
    Guys stop thinking with your emotions, and use use your brains we can't maintain a road how will we maintain a expensive machine like a helicopter, where will the monies come from, if you did not realise it, every part of the chopper has to be checked before and after every trip and there parts are costly. Plus you will need a least two good mechanics.
    • black (19/11/2024, 11:28) Like (4) Dislike (0) Reply
      @Bumble Bee
      You also forgot the constant training for the flight crew, the fuel & maintenance and the hangar space for storage from the elements. All the drug money that is seized can be used to help offset the cost along with each passenger paying for using the service.
  • Pay for a Band (19/11/2024, 11:01) Like (2) Dislike (1) Reply
    But not a helicopter. Pay for barges but not a helicopter. Pay for a hospital sign but not a helicopter. Pay for a......
  • SeaGrape Enthusiast (19/11/2024, 11:09) Like (3) Dislike (1) Reply
    I disagree with this. The BVI is the sailing capital of the Caribbean with that in mind we have daily traffic in and out of our water and ensuring safety for all inhabitants we should consider getting a helicopter. Its too often not reported the amount of complications we have at sea some not so dangerous but some also resulting in fatalities that could be easily prevented. It would also play a role in patrolling and controlling this trafficking problem we seem to have at hand. Another point is that our hospital is insufficient when dealing with severely critical conditions and having our own helicopter to airlift citizens as quickly as possible to better health care is nothing short of ideal. We always talk about developing and moving forward and improving infrastructure, however when the topic arises we have opinions like this being broadcasted.
  • Stealth (19/11/2024, 11:17) Like (4) Dislike (2) Reply
    Pure self-serving nonsense by Mr. Aspinal. I totally disagree that a helicopter is not needed. Many VI residents didn’t make it , for they didn’t make it to the lone public hospital in the territory in time. I got the receipts. In an emergency health situation, time matters, and life always matter. For centuries, residents on outlying sister islands lacked the transportation to get the to hospital in a reasonable time during an emergency health situation. Moreover, then the ridiculousness continues. Aspinal is averse to helicopter but supports a light aircraft. A fix wing aircraft needs more landing space than a helicopter. Most sister islands don’t have landing strips; a helicopter just needs a helipad. A helicopter is good insurance. It is responsible to invest in the heath and safety of VI residents, especially those on sister islands. Is it better to lament when something happens if only we had a chopper?The chopper can save lives!! Similarly, is it better after an auto accident, a hurricane , flood, etc, to lament if only we had insurance? Government main role is to provide service to the community, all the community.
  • lodger (19/11/2024, 12:33) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    To Stealth, your last sentence says it all. Get on to government, not VISAR, and see my earlier post.
  • The Commissioner (19/11/2024, 13:18) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    Perhaps in addition to blogging persons should go in to VISAR and offer their services so that the entire Territory can benefit. I am sure the good gentleman can put the "additional" resources to use as VISAR is after all a VOLUNTARY organisation.
  • LOL (19/11/2024, 14:51) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply

    We can barely maintain a %^$£"g pickup truck, it's a helicopter? Is there a stupidity contest somewhere that everyone is trying to win? SMH!

  • ... (19/11/2024, 16:01) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    It doesnt have to be a personal attack to say we should be self reliant as much as possible.

    A helicopter and a plane both is better than one.

    less 1 million dollar party or other oppsie and we can buy a plane or helicopter. The politicians are fools to not invest in the safety of the people.

  • ... (19/11/2024, 16:05) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    We got a 1 million dollar wall, 10s of millions over spent on the pier park, and they got scammed out of a 7 million dollar commercial air plane.

    Then come time there is no money to buy a aircraft for the people be it a plane or helicopter. They never played sims and went to run a country.


Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.

Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.